Gut Reactions

Immediate analysis of NFL games and news

Gut Reaction: Brodrick Bunkley

Now that John Elway is back with the Broncos, the suffering of Cleveland Browns fans can commence yet again.

Enter Brodrick Bunkley.  For whatever reason--whether Bunkley wouldn't report to the Browns or not--Bunkley won't have the pleasure of seeing grown men gorge themselves on dog biscuits.  

Instead, he's coming to Denver.

After watching Brodrick Bunkley on film last year, it's easy to see why the Broncos traded for him.

Bunkley is workmanlike; he does his job.  That's been a rarity in the last two years in Denver.

Bunkley will be a welcome addition. 

I watched two of Bunkley's game tapes.  The first was from Week 17 against the Dallas Cowboys, which Pro Football Focus (PFF) rated as Bunkley's best game.   The second was the Week 3 matchup against the Jaguars, which PFF rated as his worst game.  

Continue reading "Gut Reaction: Brodrick Bunkley"

Derrick Harvey and the mining of second-hand talent

I’m a Florida Gators fan, which everybody knows, but that’s not the reason that I like Derrick Harvey.  I think the guy has been a pretty good NFL player since he came into the League, but that he has been judged through the prism of being the eighth-overall pick in a Draft and not showing the pass-rushing production of a pick that high.

Harvey is very solid against the run, but has never shown the quick-twitch athleticism that it takes to be a dominant pass rusher.  The truth is, he’s never been that kind of player, even going back to his college days, when he got a lot of sacks.

Continue reading "Derrick Harvey and the mining of second-hand talent"

Gut Reaction: Broncos sign Marcus Thomas

For once, I agree with an agent. 

Here's what Richard Bernoski, agent for recently signed Marcus Thomas, had to say only moments ago:

We're excited about the scheme that John Fox is running, it will give Marcus Thomas a chance to reach his potential and do what he does best which is penetrate to get up field to cause chaos in the backfield. He's been the most productive defensive tackle in Denver playing in a system that didn't fit his skill-set.

Bernoski knows his client well.  There was perhaps no player who had to fight his natural tendencies more in the 3-4 defense that Josh McDaniels wanted to run during his time in Denver.  

Thomas was never a fit as a two-gap defender.  He was simply out of place.   Despite this, he played with a lot of effort and held his own as a defensive end.  

Marcus Thomas is your classic 3-technique penetrator.  He split gaps and uses his quick first step to his advantage. 

Then he tries to unleash hell.

Continue reading "Gut Reaction: Broncos sign Marcus Thomas"

Gut Reaction: Colby Whitlock

In this year's draft, the worst-kept secret in the world was the Broncos' need to acquire a defensive tackle.

Yesterday, they finally did, signing Texas Tech lineman Colby Whitlock.

Surprisingly, he might stick around.

Whitlock played a lot of 3-4 nose tackle for Texas Tech.  As you'll see from this tape, that helped him to develop a certain toughness that one doesn't see from 4-3 defensive tackles.  In the 3-4, you need to be stout at the point of attack, you need to be willing to sacrifice yourself at even the slightest hint of a double team, and you'd better have a motor that never stops.  

Continue reading "Gut Reaction: Colby Whitlock"

Gut Reaction: Nick Bellore

Note: Bellore is apparently headed to the Jets instead of Denver

Continue reading "Gut Reaction: Nick Bellore"

Gut Reaction: Bryant Browning

(Note: Browning was originally reported as agreeing with Denver, but ultimately he chose to join the St. Louis Rams)

Continue reading "Gut Reaction: Bryant Browning"

Gut Reaction: Deron Mayo

To find a future star in the NFL among undrafted rookie free agents, you could do a lot worse than looking for three things:

1) Speed

2) Speed

3) A brother with speed, who was also Defensive Rookie of the Year in 2008.

Deron Mayo may be undersized for the NFL. He's listed at 5-11 and 220 pounds.  That's why teams shied away from him in the draft.  However, like his famous brother, he brings quickness and speed.  Deron is actually faster than his older brother, and runs (by some accounts) a sub-4.4 forty-yard dash.  He's a tweener DE/OLB, who many thought would have been a good fit as a 3-4 OLB after adding a few pounds.   In fact, he had this to say recently:

People like (Denver’s) Elvis Dumervil and (Pittsburgh’s) James Harrison definitely give me hope.  I’m 5-11. I look at people like that and it gives me a lot of motivation. It’s all about learning the game. I feel like I can rush the passer from the edge. It’s just a matter of a coach or a team taking a chance on me, which I know will pay off.

Continue reading "Gut Reaction: Deron Mayo"

Gut Reaction: Mario Fannin

John Fox likes versatility in his running back combinations.   

Enter Mario Fannin.  

Fannin was Auburn's third-string running back last year.  Despite this, he was projected by some to be drafted as high as the 5th round in this year's draft.

Why?  Fannin set the building on fire at the combine with a 4.37 40-yard dash and a 37.5-inch vertical jump.  Those are numbers that Knowshon Moreno would have killed for at his combine. 

Fannin left little doubt that he's a world-class athlete by those measures.  He's also a master of catching the ball out of the backfield and has a knack for the YAC (yards after catch).

If Fannin makes the Broncos' roster, it won't be because of his running ability.  His field vision after getting the handoff has always been his weakest attribute.  It will be because Denver needs a weapon on 3rd-down-and-medium.

Continue reading "Gut Reaction: Mario Fannin"

Symphony of Destruction - Perrish Cox, Demaryius Thomas, and Cassius Vaughn

If the NFL was a game of Monopoly, yesterday Perrish Cox pulled the Go To Jail card.

Do not pass Dove Valley.  Do not collect $405,000.  

In this game, you can't roll doubles, nor can you purchase (for any amount of money) a Get Out Of Jail Free card from Demaryius Thomas or Cassius Vaughn.  They are too busy looking for cover.

Cox is easy pickins, Broncos fans.  You'll see dozens of columns over the next month criticizing his character and his integrity.  Further, you'll hear a lot of pundits play the I told you so card.  And that's just fine.  Fans aren't required to withhold judgement until all the facts are in.  While Cox is innocent until proven guilty in the court of law, as a member of the Denver Broncos, the story told in the arrest warrent is easily enough for the fans and the Broncos to run him out of town.

Roger Goodell won't be distracted by the law.  If Cox is guilty, he's in jail; if he's not, Goodell is likely to suspend him for at least six games (Roethlisberger style).   

I'm guessing that right now, John Elway could care less how well Perrish Cox plays man coverage.

He can't cover it as a member of the Denver Broncos.

Continue reading "Symphony of Destruction - Perrish Cox, Demaryius Thomas, and Cassius Vaughn"

Gut Reaction: Eighth Circuit grants stay of lockout injunction

The Eighth Circuit today granted the NFL's request for a stay, by a 2-1 majority.  In the accompanying opinion, the two concurring judges disagreed with Judge Susan Nelson's ruling that this situation was a labor dispute, and not a matter of litigation.

They went so far as to say that the NFL was likely to prevail in their appeal, which will likely occur in June.

The Court, as the NFL had openly hoped, voted along partisan lines and delivered a pro-business ruling.  Frankly, the merits of the Court's comments don't make a lot of sense to me.

The majority completely ignored the fact that the NFL agreed not to pursue a claim of a sham decertification in 1992.  The NFL wanted the NFLPA to recertify at that time, so that they'd be afforded the antitrust protection of a non-statutory labor exemption, which we've been all through here at IAOFM.

Continue reading "Gut Reaction: Eighth Circuit grants stay of lockout injunction"